Live Catch Mouse Traps – The HomeFixated Guide To Catching Mice and Keeping Your Karma Intact

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases (more).

mouse and cheese
mouse and cheese

My wife has been hearing things. At first I was alarmed. Then she told me it wasn’t voices telling her to kill me in my sleep. Instead, it was thumps, dragging and scratching sounds. “Did we forget to take our daughter out of timeout in the closet again?” I asked nervously. My wife then informed me the sounds were coming from the crawl space and inside the walls. I breathed a sigh of relief. That eliminated timeout as the issue, and saved us from an awkward talk with Child Protective Services. Since our house wasn’t known to be haunted, I ruled out a poltergeist too. Given how small the access is to the wall with the scratching sounds, I settled on mice as the likely culprit. What follows is our semi-definitive guide to catching mice humanely.

What To Buy
After doing some online research and sifting through reviews of various live-catch mouse and rodent traps, I headed to my local Lowes. There are four things you’ll want on your shopping list for this project (unless you already have them):

mousetrap peanut butter bait
Organic peanut butter not required

1) Live Catch Mouse Trap
2) Wire Mesh or Steel Wool
3) Staple Gun
4) Peanut Butter (Please note Lowes does not typically carry this)

I have to say I’m a little disappointed in the big box stores when it comes to humane pest control marketing. The rodent control wall at Lowes was a towering, expansive array of poisons and various mice torture/kill devices. They ranged from yummy poison squares to glue traps that adhere the mice to a pad until they die of starvation. Have you seen mice? They’re really cute (until they eat the wires in your wall). I thought this would also make a fun little project for our four year old daughter, and I didn’t really want to explain why daddy was snapping the necks of our cute little friends.

Step 1 – Cut-Off All Means of Entry (and Escape)
The last thing you want to do is create a revolving door effect with the mice you catch. Do a careful perimeter check and look for holes around pipes, utilities, etc. Make sure any vents are also rodent proof. Keep in mind mice can climb shrubs, trees, gutters, utility lines, etc. so don’t assume your second story is safe. Carefully secure wire mesh around any openings using a staple gun. Mice are small, so don’t underestimate what they can squeeze themselves into. According to Tomcat Rodent Control, “Rats can squeeze through a hole about the size of a nickel while mice can fit through a hole smaller than a dime.” Protect accordingly. I found steel wool handy for some of the smaller gaps. You can find more detailed Rodent-Proofing Strategies from the Tomcat, the company that makes the live catch mouse trap we used.

Step 2 – Bait Your Mouse Trap

mouse trap peanut butter
Mice love peanut butter

Now that you have your home secured you can be assured your little friends won’t just be living at your house and dining out elsewhere. If they’re not already munching on your food, expect them to be soon. It’s time to bait your trap. Peanut Butter seems to be almost universally recommended. After 24 hours without our first catch, my wife started to question the peanut butter bait strategy. She suggested we supplement the bait with cheese. This seemed perfectly reasonable until I asked what cheese we had. “We have some Brie.” she said nonchalantly. “Brie?!!” I exclaimed “There is no way in hell I’m feeding our mice brie!” While this might have been an opportunity to further enhance my Karma, I could not bear the thought of those little critters dining better than I do. It was a strong, territorial reaction, I know. Ultimately we experimented with both peanut butter and some (non-gourmet) cheese. Peanut butter was far and away the clear winner, don’t waste your time with anything else.

Step 3 – Trap Placement Strategy
We placed two traps to maximize our chance of success and learned a couple lessons in the process. The second night after we sealed up the house, we woke to discover mice had snuck into the cabinet under our kitchen sink and had a field day with our trash scraps. It was the first time they had ventured inside. We learned to remove any other source of food in known mouse haunts so that the food in the trap was their only option. Once this strategy was in place, we started catching mice. We had much more success in the kitchen than in the crawl space. The trap in the kitchen was also a lot easier to check. My advice is, if you have an area of known mouse activity inside, stick to placing your trap along a wall there and save yourself some trips to the crawl space or attic. If you’re using the same style trap as we did, you’ll also want to be sure to set the trap on a level, smooth surface. That helps eliminates false-trips or trap doors that fail to close.

Step 4 – Checking Your Mouse Trap
It definitely defeats the purpose of humane trapping if you forget to check the trap and your poor little mouse starves to death in a lonely, fecal-filled plastic tube of doom. Leaving the mice in the traps long also increases the chances they might nibble their way out (something a few people using this style of mouse trap reported). We checked our traps several times a day and surprisingly caught quite a few during daytime hours. If the door to the trap is closed, there’s a good chance you’ve caught a mouse!

Step 5 – Release Strategies

live catch release
My wife managed to get this lightning fast critter in a photo – Note armored gloves in case this rabid beast turns on me

In our case, we have a little open field across the street. I did the first release honors, donning gloves in case we accidentally trapped a wild, rabid, miniature chupacabra. Instead, I popped open the door and after a brief pause, a cute little mouse launched out of the trap and to freedom. Sure he might be lunch for the local cat or a hawk, but I’m OK with that. On catch number two we decided gloves were overkill and my daughter took the honors.

m mouse release
Pink boots are essential for all mice release expeditions

This little friend was so fast I missed catching a pic, but my daughter had a blast letting him go. After we kept catching more mice there was some debate about whether the same mouse was somehow sneaking back into our house for a new snack each day. Mice brains aren’t very big, and they are essentially taken blindfolded to their release point. If you’re paranoid on this front, you could always take your captured mouse for a drive, spin around in circles a few times and make sure the mouse doesn’t have GPS going on his iPhone before releasing.

Don’t Assume You Got Them All
After our first catch, I was basking in the glow of a successful hunt and capture. It’s easy to let the rush of mouse hunting go to your head at this point. Don’t get cocky now. Set your trap again and wait. In our case, we caught five mice in the span of one week. We had a steady flow of one catch a day, but your results may vary. We left our trap out another five days or so before declaring mission accomplished. On a side note, definitely do not declare mission accomplished with any fanfare (like on an aircraft carrier), you’ll only be humiliated by more mice if you do. According to Wikipedia, “The average gestation period is 20 days” and, “The average litter size is 10–12 during optimum production.” That might explain why we found more signs of mice after our victory declaration.

Despite being cute, mice can leave an impressive distribution of poo and pee, often on things you normally like to eat. They’re also infamouse (get it?) for nibbling on wiring, which can make for a very spendy repair job if you have to dig into any walls. Our mouse-trapping adventure wound up being a success, and we hope with a little help from this article, yours will too.

tomcat live catch mouse trap
At under $10 we found the Tomcat Live Catch Mouse Trap a bargain

At around $8, I was skeptical our Tomcat Mousetrap would work. I was even more skeptical when I felt how easily both the bait door and the trap door opened and closed. Despite the skepticism, the trap performed remarkably well. I can’t really imagine it having worked any better. You can find the Tomcat Livecatch Mousetrap for about $4 on Amazon, roughly half what we paid at Lowes. Whatever you do, don’t bait your trap with Brie though!

Photo of author

About Marc Lyman

Marc grew up under a brave single mom who "encouraged" home improvement on the family home. Early toddler gifts included a tool set, and even a cordless Bosch drill when cordless drills first came out. In grade school (give or take a few years), Marc's mom said, "We need to cut down some trees. . . . here's a chainsaw." A father figure also involved Marc in many home improvement projects, including a summer of home remodeling in Palo Alto, CA. Toss in some Obsessive Compulsive personality traits researching everything home improvement related. The end result: a genetically pre-disposed, socially sculpted home improvement machine! For his complete profile, please visit our About page. Really, it's worth it.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get access to free prizes, product sneak-peeks, reviews, how-to's and much more!

More Info | Email Privacy

19 thoughts on “Live Catch Mouse Traps – The HomeFixated Guide To Catching Mice and Keeping Your Karma Intact”

  1. That was hilariously written man. Some people would be like nooo i cant say that about forgetting the child in a closet lol. Bravo

  2. Hi! A few quick comments to hopefully help others reading this. First of all, great post, I love that you involved your little one in showing compassion to animals, even pesky ones.

    But I did want to give others reading this article a heads up. There was a study done by the CDC (not sure if I can post links here but you can easily find it by searching this title: “Navigational Instinct: A Reason Not to Live Trap Deer Mice in Residences”). They tagged and released various mice at various distances and found that the adult mice could find their way back home at distances of 1.25 miles away! And they had to traverse hills, woods, streams, etc to do so. The study concludes that this is a reason not to live trap, but I absolutely disagree with that conclusion. I would caution instead to simply bring them for a longer “scenic drive” that you might think is necessary. I am in the process of live trapping “my” mice right now and I’m dropping them no less than 3 miles away. That might be further than necessary but I’d rather do this once and be sure they won’t return.

    I choose places near streams or water sources and I leave them with a little “picnic” of cat food or sunflower seeds to get them started while they adjust to their new surroundings.

    This article smartly points out the importance of blocking re-entry points in the home, but of course that’s not always feasible, so I thought I would share this tip. Oh; one more thing! I am also discovering that “my” mice have varying tastes! They aren’t as interested in peanut butter as I assumed they would be, but some of them love cookies! A broken cookie will get then to go right in. Broken/crumbled biscuit style dog treats are also a favorite so try different things. And when I bring them for their scenic drive I leave them with whatever treat they went in for as a reward for their “cooperation”.

  3. The mouse walked to his favorite haunt in my bedroom. Right next to the trap, under a large envelop. It has peanut butter and before that, toasted almond slivers. The mouse was right there, back and forth – never entered the trap. What now?

  4. Have tried 3 nights with the live trap, no success. They eat the p-nut butter but somehow walk on out to roam the house EVERYWHERE! Is there a trick to setting these up, appears simple enuf, Thanx for any suggestions

    • I caught two the first day. Use peanut butter and most important place trap along wall. Mice generally hug the wall when they roam even when frightened. Make sure you look into trap when releasing it. I thought the trap simply tripped and nothing inside when I opened it. When I brought trap back in house to reset, the mouse jumped out into kitchen. It must have held on inside the container.

  5. We rescued baby oscar in our yard! Placed him in a Rubbermaid tote with a bed of cotton balls and seed and water!! In two weeks before we had a chance to release him he was able to jump out and now is loose in our garage!! Husband is on his way to lowes!! 🙂

  6. I strongly believe in using these traps, I caught 4 baby mice and counting in this trap. Two were in it one night and then one and another one. I will continue using these traps if I need to. They’re great and the furry little critters aren’t hurt or killed.

  7. Hey,

    I set one of these and checked in the morning. the door was shut, but no mouse. the peanut butter had been eaten and there was mouse poop inside.

    How did he get out?

    • So,someone else has experienced the “Hamburger Heaven” syndrome. Peanut butter gone,pee and poo in its place No more Mr. nice guy.Guillotine like structure to be deployed this evening to thwart Houdini mouse.

  8. Those certainly are cute boots on my granddaughter. I must admit to a preference for cheese as bait but then as a former hunter and fisherman, I never worried about catch and release. I’m sure that some smelly cheese (think gorgonzola) would work wonderfully. LOL.

    • We still have one little mouse on the run that apparently doesn’t like peanut butter. I’ve begrudgingly agreed to a brie bait test. Definitely sticking to catch release since I hear “catch and eat” isn’t very attractive with mice! ; )

  9. I will have to pick up one of these since the mouse I have is a regular Houdini. When I used regular mousetraps he licked the peanut butter clean off the trap without tripping it. He also has expensive tastes and regularly skips the easy stuff like crackers and sugar to feast on European chocolate bars. Maybe some Brie in one of these traps will do the trick.


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.