Hit It! The Four Hammers Every DIYer and Home Remodeler Should Own

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases (more).

Many millennia ago, the first prehistoric DIY caveman got a flash of inspiration, picked up a rock, and brought it crashing down on something. In the process, he probably also crushed his thumb, which was likely responsible for the first prehistoric string of obscenities (“Son of a stinking pterodactyl-breath Neanderthal, that HURTS!!). Ever since then, striking tools, in the form of hammers, have played a major role in shaping our world. And not just by flattening our thumbs; although the hammer is generally thought of as “just a tool,” its inherent danger and destructive potential, as illustrated in the following video, shouldn’t be ignored… 

The 16-oz baby brother of my daily-use Estwing, which is temporarily unavailable…

I got my start many years ago as a framing carpenter. The most important purchases I made after receiving my first paycheck were an unbreakable thermos (Buffalo winters are COLD!), a good tool belt, and an Estwing 24-oz framing hammer. The Thermos fell victim to a front-end loader (“unbreakable” has its limits, apparently), and the tool belt wore out after several years, but the Estwing is still banging away.

Doing a lot of brick or rock work? There’s a hammer for that!

There are a lot of different types of hammers out there, encompassing pretty much any specialty you can think of—roofing, drywall , masonry and rock work, engineers, hobbyists and upholsterers, metalworking—they even have cute pink girly hammers . If you work in a trade that requires a specific type of hammer, you’ve probably learned what the right tool is for you. If you’re an all-around DIYer, though, you’ll be looking for tools that help you accomplish the tasks you’re most likely to take on—a bit of demolition man (or woman—with or WITHOUT the pink hammer!) and a megadose of Bobby (or Bobbie!) the Builder. With a hammer from each, or even most, of the four categories below, you should be able to do a bang-up job on any DIY or remodeling project.

May the Force be With You…The BFH

When you need maximum persuasive ability, bring the BFH

We’ll start out right at the top of the food chain. When it’s time to smash the hell out of something, whether it be an old sidewalk, a stud wall that has to go away, or your ex’s abandoned collection of “It’s a small world after all” singing dolls, nothing beats the long-handled sledge. The long-handled sledge is known in construction parlance as the “BFH” or “Big Freakin’ Hammer” (definitions may vary slightly). You may also hear it referred to as The Persuader, for its ability to persuade pretty much anything to move/disintegrate/become flat. Another somewhat less-common use of the BFH can be seen in this rather novel demonstration of sledgehammer technique (HomeFixated lawyers insist that we state, “Don’t try this at home, or anywhere else.”) –

And this one, the sledgehammer workout—who knew a hammer could be so versatile and fun!

They look a lot prettier before you start bashing stuff…

With a 36″ handle, usually hickory or fiberglass, you get a lot of leverage to wallop whatever is the object of your ire. Available in weights from around 5 pounds up to about 24 or more, a good all-around basher is the 16-pounder. I’ve had mine for several years, and haven’t come across much that it couldn’t persuade. Available at Amazon or any home center for around $30-45. We also like the Wilton BASH (with BASH standing for Bad Ass Sledge Hammer), which offers a serious durability thanks to its “unbreakable” handle.

Persuader Jr.

Brother and Sister Sledge, ready to get the job done

Next up (or down) in your hammer repertoire should be the short-handled sledge. There will be a lot of times when the long-handled sledge packs just a bit too much punch for the job at hand. It’s also pretty heavy and can be a little tough to control, especially in a tight space. Don’t believe me? Try the hammer-to-head trick in the demonstration above and have your ibuprofen ready. (HomeFixated lawyers insisted I delete that suggestion). A decent size small sledge is the three-pounder. It has plenty of weight to propel a cold chisel through a brick, or to bang that header into place. It works pretty well for crushing your empty beverage cans at the end of the day, too, to save space in the recycling bin. You can find a decent one at any home center, or of course at Amazon, for $10-20.

Not Just For Whack-A-Mole…

The rubber mallet provides a gentler form of persuasion

From time to time, you’ll have something that needs persuading in a somewhat gentler fashion. If you’re working on your car, and need to tap a bearing race into place, assembling a balky piece of furniture, or setting pavers for a patio, you need something that provides the necessary oomph, but with a bit of give. A steel hammer head can mar the surface when it makes contact, and may also make that contact with a bit more force than you want. A good rubber mallet will provide much more control over how your persuasion is administered, and will generally leave no evidence behind, in the form of chipped edges, cracked pavers, or dented cradle parts. Available from the usual suspects, including Amazon, for under $10.

Let Me Frame It This Way

Last in our hard-hitting roundup, the tool most likely to get used on every project—the framing, or carpenter’s, hammer. Talk to ten framing carpenters, and you’re unlikely to find two with the same hammer. Framing hammers come in a multitude of styles and sizes, from a multitude of makers, and there are a lot of good ones out there.

My old 16-oz Craftsman, still ready to swing into action

When I first began nailing together stud walls, swinging my shiny new Craftsman 16-oz hammer, and missing the nail about a third of the time, my foreman Ross’s good-natured refrain of “Hit it!” would come wafting across the job site. That was quite a while back, and a lot has changed since then. For the past three-plus decades, my Estwing 24-oz framing hammer (which replaced the Craftsman after the first week, mainly because I wanted a hammer with more banging power) has been getting the job done, and my accuracy has improved—I now miss the nail only about 25% of the time. The Estwing has a solid handle and a rubber grip, and the 24-oz weight of the head can put away a 16p nail in two or three strokes (assuming I actually HIT IT!). The straight claw has survived over thirty years of prying, nail pulling, ice chipping, and general abuse, and is still good to go.

New technology claims to provide more striking force with less weight

Hammers are available with several types of handle: solid metal, hollow metal, wood, graphite, fiberglass, even titanium. I like the heft and feel of the solid metal, but it does transfer a lot of vibration to the user; also, the weight of the hammer can be fatiguing after a long day of banging. Some newer hammers, such as the $200 Stiletto TB15MC TiBone 15-Ounce Titanium Milled-Face Hammer  or the $39 Dewalt DWHT51138 15 Ounce MIG Weld Checker Faced Framing Hammer,  claim to provide the same striking force as a 28-ounce hammer, with only a 15-ounce head. That could save a lot of wear and tear on the old arm. Unless you’re a pro, or have a lot of disposable income, the Dewalt would likely do just fine. It has the straight claw; some users prefer a curved claw for pulling nails, but I’ve never had a problem using a straight claw, and it’s way better for prying things apart.

Your best bet is to go to a home improvement or hardware store with a good assortment of hammers, and try several out. Grab the handle near the end, like you’re shaking hands with it, and find one you like the heft of, one that feels good in your hand, with a weight you’d feel comfortable swinging for a few hours (although they may get touchy if you test that out in the store). Buy the best quality you can afford, and your hammer will take a pounding for decades to come.

Hammer Time

Finally, before you go thumping away, here are a couple of other points I want to hammer home…
If you want your hammer to be a work of art, AND to have a cool name, you could do worse than the Hardcore Hades, available along with a line of other similarly stylin’ hammers and axes, from Basecampx for $115 Canadian. It has a 19-oz head and an 18” Tennessee hickory handle. (Note: they are currently sold out of this model.)

The hammer from hell…the Hardcore Hades
Can’t get enough about hammers? Head to Alaska’s Hammer Museum!

If you’re interested in all things hammer, check out the Hammer Museum in Haines, Alaska. There you’ll find fascinating info on the history of the mighty implement, and an online store where you can purchase your own “I got hammered in Haines, Alaska” T-shirt. A lot of interesting pictures are online, too, including several hammer sculptures, and five old hammers from the “how not to hit your fingers” lineup.

A hammer that could save your life? Hit it!

Next up, my wise friend Deb urged me to include a hammer that might just save your life. Most vehicles in use today have power windows. There is a good chance that the window could become inoperable in the event of a crash, fire, or submersion in water, trapping the occupants inside. Auto safety glass is tough to break, especially in an emergency situation; ResQMe has come up with a hammer with a pointed, hardened striking surface, that will shatter the glass and let you escape. It also has a built-in seat belt cutter, in case the belt becomes jammed. The Life Hammer, along with more information, including a video, are available from (where else!) Amazon for about $15. Hey, my Mom even got one for me!
And finally, if you aspire to hammer greatness, prepare to be inspired by this happy, hammerin’ guy (and this version even has subtitles!) Enjoy!


Photo of author

About Phil

Phil’s path to the pinnacle of success as HomeFixated’s Senior Writer was long and twisted. At various stages of his life, he worked as a framing carpenter, attended motorcycle mechanics school, served as an Army MP, did a hot and itchy stint installing insulation in Phoenix, owned and operated a small contracting firm doing residential renovations, and worked as an employee of a major airline (Motto: We’re not happy ‘til YOU’RE not happy). He is currently semi-retired, but continues to take on little projects, such as the total renovation of an old farmhouse. Yes, he is a slow learner. Future projects include a teardown restoration of his 1965 BMW motorcycle, and designing and building a kick-ass playhouse for his grandsons. Phil loves spending time outdoors, hanging out with family and friends, cool tools, and a cold IPA when beer o'clock rolls around.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get access to free prizes, product sneak-peeks, reviews, how-to's and much more!

More Info | Email Privacy

11 thoughts on “Hit It! The Four Hammers Every DIYer and Home Remodeler Should Own”

  1. Great hammer article piece. I just bought a new home and started to pick up new tools, and I will make sure I get a good tool belt which never occurred to me how important it is. Thanks for this tip.

    • Thanks, Trent, and congrats on the new home! One bonus piece of advice: When buying tools (or most other things), always buy the best quality you can afford. They generally last longer, perform better, and make you a happier human.

  2. I know there are a TON of other hammers out there but one of my regular go to hammers lately is a 4lb Estwing dead blow mallet. I use it in lieu of the 4 lb sledge because I can hit pry bars and the like without scary bounce-back, and with much less noise and vibration. It’s also a great framing persuader because it doesn’t destroy the wood you’re trying to get in place like a sledge or framing hammer would.

    Course… when you’re really just trying to break things I’ve become a big fan of the Stanley FUBAR (whoever named this got away with it by coming up with “Functional Utility BAR”). That’s what FUBAR stands for, right? 😉

  3. My personal favorite is my SLUF (Short Fat Ugly “Feller”). It’s a full sized sledge, customized with its handle cut off at 17″. It was given to me by a foul-mouthed middle-eastern gentleman with muscled forearms the size of gallon paint cans. He drove electrical grounding rods like they were thumbtacks.

    • Yep, when you look at it, that’s just the first term that comes to mind. Aircraft mechanics even use the term (although when they do, you might want to start looking for a new flight…)


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.